Wednesday, 25 March 2020

Lake Ohrid and the Péchot story



We are sorry not to meet our friends at the 16mm Peterborough AGM and Show. For the greater good, we are all staying at home. It is a chance to read, dream and plan expeditions we can undertake once travel restrictions are lifted. We start with a picture of the fascinating Péchot-Bourdon locomotive as it has several links with Lake Ohrid, links we discovered when researching our Péchot models and 'Colonel Péchot: Tracks To The Trenches'
Print of a Péchot-Bourdon locomotive, designed to run on portable track. Print courtesy Raymond Duton
It is an area we long to visit. Ohrid and its sister lake Prespa  are found in the Balkans peninsula, the vast peninsula which separates the Adriatic from the Black Sea. The Balkans are on the crossroads between Europe and Asia, so are generally interesting, but we’d like to focus on the Ohrid area.
Ohrid appeals to my Scottish soul because it has affinities with our own Loch Ness. The names of both lakes share the Scottish ‘huh’. Both lakes act as boundaries. Loch Ness lies along an ancient fault-line separating the eastern and western Scottish highlands while Lake Ohrid and Prespa are also in a borderland. They separate the worlds of Mediterranean Europe and the lands to the south. The lakes are survivors from a geotectonic depression which started perhaps five million years ago. The corrugations – rugged mountains and deep lakes of the Balkans - are the effect of the movement of vast tectonic plates which apply unimaginable pressures on the surface of the land.
Lake Ohrid is Europe’s oldest. How do we know that? Because of the variety of plants and animals which are found nowhere else. At the risk of boring you with Lake Ohrid facts, for its area, it is the most bio-diverse lake in the world. Species evolve at a certain rate, so the theory goes – it a bit like estimating the age of a hedgerow. So the unique waterweed and fishes are interesting in themselves but also suggest that Ohrid has been there for a million years. The lake never silts up. Although sediment is continually brought in by feeder streams, the restless earth sucks it away. They call it subduction.
Unfortunately, our own Loch Ness is rather short on aquatic life – too cold - so this method can’t be used to calculate its age but, naturally, being a good Scot, I believe that Loch Ness too conceals its own mysteries.
Lake Ohrid is the deepest lake of the Balkans. It is not the deepest lake in Europe - that distinction belongs to Loch Ness. Almost as beautiful and strange are the springs which constantly feed it. About 50% of its water comes in this way, from an underground system which links Prespa to Ohrid. This effect has a respectable scientific explanation; we are in karst country where water dissolves away rock to find underground channels. It disappears only to reappear miles away. From Celtic times, we Scots have found springs quite delightful, so allow me my little moment of wonder.
Southern Balkans, centred on Salonika/Thessaloniki circa 1920. Ohrid and Prespa are just west of Bitola. Courtesy Times Publishing
The water of lake Ohrid has two exits. The obvious one is the Black Drin River which flows through Albania to the Adriatic. There is another significant one that is  invisible. That is evaporation, which channels no less than 40% of the water away.
The lakes deserve to be better known – and the fact that they aren't, is a tragedy. They lie over the cultural and political fissures which divide the Balkans. At present, the western shores of Ohrid are Albanian, the eastern (roughly) in  the Republic of Macedonia (Former Yugoslavia. Lake Prespa is divided between RoM, Albania and Greece. Another block to them being better known is that they are also known as Ochrida and Presba.
This should not in itself be a problem. Lake Geneva, aka Lac Leman, has French shores and Swiss shores. Everyone gets along. People live on the French side and commute to the Swiss side. Tourists can enjoy both. Alas, tourists can’t easily take a boat and sail from one side of Ohrid to the other. Modern maps, so we are told, don’t even show both sides of the lake, which seems to float off into a misty neverland as you look from the shore.
Close-up of the area shows Presba/Presba and Ochrida/Ohrid. Salonika is to the south-east with Lake Lake Dojran due north of it. Snaking red national boundaries are very obvious. Courtesy Times Publishing
Its human history goes back millennia. From nearby, pottery has been found that is over seven THOUSAND years old. The decorations are as fine as anything produced by a modern artist. Tourists should also be inspired by ‘To The Lake: A Balkan Journey’ by Kapka Kassabova. As she puts it very kindly, history is still being made here - ancient tensions have still not been resolved.
Our maps, courtesy of Times Publishing, show the lakes circa 1920.
Another reason to visit is that Ohrid played a pivotal role in the Péchot story. True to character, it lay in a disputed no-man’s-land between the Allied Macedonian Front and the Bulgarian sector of the Central Powers. In every Front, generals attempted the breakthrough and on every Front, the usual result was stalemate. The German Spring Offensives of March/April 1918 came the nearest to punching through the British Front, but never quite succeded. After four years of war, the concept of breakthrough had acquired a mythical status. The Russian Front, it was true, had crumbled, but this was because of pressure from home rather than a knockout military blow.
It was here, in the unpromising and rugged Balkan terrain, that the stalemate was broken by the one true military breakthrough of the First World War. Yet the battle of Monastir is hardly remembered because the place has changed its name. Monastir has vanished from the map
(A bit of backstory) In 1915, the Bulgarians entered the War on the side of the Central Powers. Their incentive was Serbian territory. The Allies formed the Macedonian Front to oppose them. The British frontline, somewhat unwisely, followed the valley of the Struma river and its tributary the Strumitza. Their main enemies were mosquitoes carrying malaria which caused many more casualties than the Bulgarians. The French and Serbs were to their west, on a Front running from from Lake Dohran/Dojran to Prespa and Ohrid. It was, to put it mildly, rough ground. But there were no mosquitoes and the Serbs were almost in home territory. One big disadvantage was the lack of transport. There were few railways anyway and the north-south links had been cut by the Bulgarians.
Various designs of portable prefabricated track were used by both sides in the first world war. If they could, they used captured material, as these jumbled tracks suggest. Photo Malcolm Wright
 In 1916, the Serbian-French were fighting south of the little railway town of Florina, in the valley of the Echisu/Ekhisu, in the southern headwaters of the Varna river. Over the next couple of years they pushed their way north along the track of the railway towards Monastir (modern Bitola) to the south of Ohrid. How did they transport the big guns, and more importantly, the ammunition?
The traditional way was by mule, 70kg per mule, quite inadequate for modern warfare. The iron road had to return; a 60cm portable railway with its freight-carrying capacity. General Franchet d’Esperey, field commander, asked for daily reports on progress of the line down the Ekhisu valley, so highly did he esteem the value of 60cm. The final assault on Monastir/Bitola could not take place until 60cm was in place. By September 15th 1918, all was ready.
The battle for Monastir/Bitola was savage, involving trains, guns, planes and old-fashioned cavalry charges. The breakthrough happened in the Cerna river valley. By September 20th, the hole in the Bulgarian defences was 25 km deep, by the 25th, well over 50 km. At the most northerly point of the breakthrough, Serbs were entering Istip (Ishtip). It was a classic breakthrough, the attackers making their way through the weak point and fanning outwards. The map is like a refractive pattern,  waves making their way through a weak point in a barrier and then spreading out.
The Balkan Front (double line) 15thSeptember 1918, centred on Monastir/Bitola, Ohrid and Prespa lying to the west.The broken lines show the stages of the breakthrough, successively 20th, 25th, 30th September and then 5th and 12th October. Illustration magazine Courtesy Malcolm Wright
The northern shore of Lake Ohrid was not taken until September 30th. By then the Bulgarian Government had agreed an Armistice with the French, valid from midnight. At this point, the British troops roused themselves and started thrashing the Bulgarians. Given the situation, this was not quite cricket.
After the Bulgarian Armistice, it was only a matter of time before the collapse of the other Central Powers. In the words of Prosper Péchot’s proud son, all could be credited to his father’s railway inventions. Once the War was over, all the track and rolling stock were safely gathered into French military depots,
This area reappears in the Péchot story. During the Second World War, the Nazis confiscated all the French military material. Most was scrapped including almost all Péchot-Bourdon locomotives. Two survived the War, one being relocated to the Dresden area in what was then the DDR and one came to Pozega in what is now Serbia. This precious survivor spent more than 60 years a few kilometres north of Ohrid. This Serbian Péchot-Bourdon is in France for restoration – a treasure of history.
Rough country! After the breakthrough, French colonial troops take a Bulgarian position. Illustration magazine. Picture courtesy Malcolm Wright

Saturday, 7 March 2020

Wrightscale WD or Péchot kits



Our model kits include Welsh narrow gauge items, the Péchot wagon and British War Department bogies.
Wrightscale 16mm Péchot wagon detail
You may be wondering which to choose from these apparently disparate items. The designs are all connected, but before you buy, you may like to know the 'why?' and 'wherefore?' of each.
As we British are proud to relate, we were pioneers in railway development. The Welsh corner of Britain was particularly inventive, especially in narrow gauge. It was a combination of geology and ingenuity. Northern Wales has an abundance of slate, known for millennia as a good roofing material. What was produced in Wales had to stay in Wales until it could be exported and narrow gauge railways provided the missing link between the slate and the ports.
Detail of 16mm WD class D wagon on Wrightscale bogies
The Talyllyn, Corris and Festiniog railways were born this way, firstly with horse-drawn freight and then with locomotives. The Festiniog developed the well-loved Fairlie locomotive which pulled four-wheeled slate wagons down to Portmadog.
Wales had lessons for the French. They had compartmentalised ideas about railways. There were the ‘serious’ gauges – standard gauge and one metre – and light ones – very narrow gauges of 60 cm and less. From the mid-eighteen seventies, the Decauville company sold portable track in 40 and 50cm gauges. In the early eighteen eighties, they introduced a portable ‘military’ gauge but this tested the technology to the limit and was less than successful.
Four ton wagon typical of the narrow gauge freight wagons before the Péchot revolution. Photo courtesy MD Wright
Along came Prosper Péchot and combined the best of Welsh and Decauville then infused a spark of personal genius. He produced a sturdy portable system on which could run rugged and adaptable ten tonne bogie wagons. A significant number have survived to this day. Revolutionary features included: 60cm gauge; bogie-mounted wagons 6m by 1.7m (about 20’ by 5’8”); low centre of gravity for a wagon with a central well; adaptability ensured by stanchions; bogies which had compensatory as well as vertical springing; coupling attached to the bogies rather than to the wagon body; brake could be applied to every bogie wheel; a prominent brake-wheel at each end; ten tonne wagons with capacity for 8 tonnes of freight.
His design was copied and adapted; by 1918, there were thousands of kilometres of track on which ran tens of thousands of ten tonne bogie wagons. The bulk of this material was sold off as War surplus – some track, wagons and locomotives returning to the land where it all began, Wales.
Ten tonne bogie wagon of 1895 after the Péchot revolution. It still has the traditional couplings,  attached tothe wagon body. Drawing by Victor Rose. Courtesy MD Wright
Malcolm has celebrated the Péchot designs, both the originals and important adaptations.

Even while the French military were experimenting with Péchot designs, the German Army were looking on. By early 1888, they were beginning to produce their own versions. They moved from 72 and 75cm gauge to 60cm, from four wheeled wagons to ten tone bogie wagons and from horse drawn to locomotive haulage. Yes, German engineers and their ‘Pioneer’ railway troops were among the best for the time.
But no, they were quite capable of industrial espionage. Paul Decauville caught them at it, as he explained to the French Government. In 1907, when the sugar-works at Cramaille took delivery of a 60cm gauge railway by Aubineau, they were soon visited by ‘technicians’ from Orenstein and Koppel. In no time at all, O&K were selling suspiciously similar 60cm wagons. Eric Fresné goes so far to say ‘the O&K wagons were ‘furiously inspired’ by the Aubineau ones’. (’70 years de chemins de fer betteraviers’ p 113)
The German adapted the pirated design to produce their own Brigadewagen (military wagon). Although the important features were retained – 6m approx by 1.7, bogie mounted, brake to every bogie-wheel, coupling through sprung bogies, 8 tonne capacity etc, they made changes.  The bogies were lighter and the wagon body was a comparatively simple framework with wood instead of steel plate. The wagon bodies did not have the well and were more easily adapted than the all-steel Péchot design. For the standard Brigadewagen, the idea of stanchions was retained, though they were usually seen attached to wooden sides. The bogie couplings also provided the springing – an arrangement which was both economical and effective. Overall, they were cheaper to make. The bogies projected a generous 50cm beyond the wagon body, making the life of the Bremser (brakesman) safer and more comfortable.
Brigadewagen on a slope. Line drawing courtesy Eric Fresné
By the time the First World War started, the Germans had a considerable stock of material. The French had a couple of hundred Péchot wagons (modèle artillerie 88) which had been in service since 1888. Once the Western Front was established and hundreds of miles of trench had to be supplied, the French realised their need for more wagons. Most of what they ordered was of a lighter pattern, reminiscent of the Brigadewagen as well as the artillerie 88. It was known as the Decauville 15.
By 1916, the British, though initially sceptical, began to admit that 60cm had advantages. They produced their own War Department design, but with similar features to the Péchot design. This was produced to metric rather than Imperial scale. Can you imagine what torment this would have been to the Eurosceptics of the time! Rather than sticking to a standard shape, they produced a number of wagon bodies. The Classes E and F had a well, useful for transporting bulky loads.
When the USA joined the War, they immediately designed their own military narrow gauge system, known as Pershing. Another nation of Imperial measurement, they too were forced to bow to the Péchot design. Their locomotives and rolling-stock ran on 60cm gauge. The Pershing was a bogie wagon. Each bogie was fitted with brakes and a brakewheel. The couplings were to the bogie not the wagon body.
16mm model of WD class D wagon on Wrightscale bogies

These later designs were all more prolific than the Péchot original but there was a catch. Although there were thousands of examples of these alternative designs, they did not have the sheer staying power of the artillerie 88. When World War One ended, the Germans had to hand over most of their 60cm gauge material. This and Allied material were used as temporary railways to restore and rebuild the ruins of the Western Front. Afterwards, they were sold off. In France, agricultural systems such as for sugar-beet were the main beneficiaries. English and Welsh quarries also bought surplus stock. Thus the grand-children of the original designs came home to Wales. Being of wood and light steel construction they had a short life. There are few photos, and these show them in a very poor state.
WD wagon photographed in the 1980s Photo courtesy J. Hawkesworth
Eric Fresné is not a fan of the Péchot design which he describes as ‘a veritable monster, heavy and over-engineered’. (Betteraviers page 114). Without appreciating the contradiction, he goes on (page 115) to say ‘the Army took great care to return the Péchot wagons to their bases and depots once the job of (post-war) reconstruction was over’ These ‘monsters’ are now beginning to reappear to great acclaim and can be seen at preserved railways in the UK and France. Though few in number, those Péchot wagons just keep rolling along.
Péchot wagon 2015, minus stanchions but still going strong. MD Wright
Sources: ‘Colonel Péchot: Tracks To The Trenches’ Sarah Wright
‘Chemins de fre betteraviers’ Eric Fresné  A French language treasure trove
‘La Voie de 60’ Dr Christian Cénac 

Thursday, 20 February 2020

Wren or Tattoo or Péchot



We were sorry to learn of the death of Mr Dowd, another great character of the 16mm scale world. Among many people who remember him with affection – Peter was a generous host and prolific writer - we pass on our condolences to his family. His Ruby Mine garden railway layout was known to many and I mention it below.

Thank you to all friends of Wrightscale – those who have liked our products and who share our interest in historic 2’ and 60cm gauge railways. I’d like to wonder aloud, ‘Why do we share this passion?’ and then wonder where this shared passion has taken us all over the years.
So, firstly, here is a little about our interest. As you perhaps know, the story of 2’ gauge goes back to the early Festiniog, then crosses the Channel to France. From 1874, Paul Decauville was experimenting with narrow gauge portable railways – and took an interest in developments in Wales.
The Welsh slate quarries were where many of the ideas behind military narrow gauge were first conceived. This layout features a Wrightscale Hunslet 0-4-0. Photo MD Wright
An officer in the French Artillery, Prosper Péchot, combined the Decauville and Welsh ideas and added a sprinkling of genius. He came up with portable railways which combined the impossible. As they say ‘If it’s difficult we do it. The impossible takes a little longer’ The Péchot system which he devised could be laid in a matter of days yet convey serious tonnages at surprising speed. A laden locomotive could travel at 12 k.p.h. at a time when horse and cart could only manage walking pace. Even better, it did not need feeding and resting.
The Péchot wagon could carry 10 tonnes of freight on track that would have been at home on a Welsh quarry. Thanks to its bogies and innovatiove suspension,, it could manage tight bends. Wrightscale model
A measure of the merit of an idea is how long it takes to copy. The Germans rapidly took up his ideas and developed their own Feldbahn system, a splendid amalgam of industrial espionage and original thinking. Furthermore, they invested heavily, which, until 1914, the French were reluctant to do. Other countries were obliged to follow suit. By 1916, the British had ordered 1000 miles of 60cm gauge track, a truly British mixture of metric and Imperial measurements.
After 1918, these vast networks, totalling six to seven thousand kilometres, were gradually dismantled and stock sold off. Many examples survived through the 20th century, but gradually, the vast network of 60cm gauge that existed in 1918 was forgotten by all but a few enthusiasts.
Gradually the part that 60 cm railways played has become recognised and relics have become treasures. Amazingly, the French Army hung on to some of the Péchot system until the late 1990s. These survivors have recently found a place in preserved railways and excited much interest. After years in the wilderness, the prototype is gathering enthusiasts.
Examples such as this Péchot wagon are begionning to be seen on preserved railways. Although well over 100 years old, it is in comparatively good condition. Taken at Apedale by MD Wright
Models reflecting bygone days are also beginning to attract interest. While of course there will always be a place for freelance models, there is a joy and challenge to creating a creating a prototype, or partly prototypical, railway.
The layouts that give the most pleasure, ie attract people back again and again, are the probable impossible. So perhaps not a dead-scale model of York Station, but one which could have existed even though it didn't.
We come back to Peter Dowd, mentioned above. He wanted more than just a freelance layout round which he and friends could run their locomotives. He created for it a story, a 2’ gauge Burmese ruby mine that never was, but should have been. Ancient Burma (now Myanmar) was the source of this ‘Lord of the Stones.’ The ruby is a form of corundum, as is the sapphire. Because of the way that ruby crystals form, corundum with a trace of chromium, large deep-crimson specimens are rare, consequently very valuable. The finest of all rubies, certainly up to the mid-twentieth century, came from northern Burma, hence the story created by Peter Dowd.
Tattoo emerging from the jungle? Wrightscale model photographed by David Provan
The working of this fictitious ruby mine generated a volume of spoil which had to be removed from the workings. A Kerr Stuart Tattoo, developed in the early 20th century could do the job. This was a locomotive which combined a neat wheelbase with considerable power and endurance, unlikely to fail on a slope with a train of spoil-wagons behind it … The management of the 1/19th scale mine therefore ordered a Wrightscale Tattoo.
In a similar way, Malcolm’s own layout has a story. It is a quarry railway set on a forested hillside in the Britain of the late Twenties. Much of the stock, such as the WD wagons, is War Surplus. Other wagons are home-made. Even the bridge has a history, built from a dismantled military viaduct. Somewhere off-scene, the system has a link to standard gauge; locomotives from elsewhere, some to a freelance design, appear on visits.
The greatest pleasure of railway modelling is an educated imagination - combined with art and ingenuity.
How do Wrightscale products add to this pleasure?
The Wren is a dainty locomotive. Wrightscale16mm  model.
These days, it is possible to buy locomotives which aspire to be Wrightscale.  If you want a rapid-prototyped Quarry Hunslet, it can be had, in all its resin and plastic glory. If you want a Wren in 7/8 “ scale, there is one available. If you want an unashamed rip-off, there is the WD Baldwin 4-6-0 reverse-engineered from one of our models. The castings are exquisite – so they should be – but they have a tiresome habit of not holding together properly. The rip-off artists forgot (or couldn’t be bothered anyway) that when a casting is taken from a casting, it shrinks a little.
As there are imitations and similar models out here, is there any joy for our customers who have paid a little more for the genuine article?
The first advantage in buying Wrightscale is that the imitators have bestowed on your original the sincerest form of flattery. They recognised that its design is a powerful blend of art and practical ability. Making a working steam model is far more than shrinking an original, any more than a healthy baby is a miniature adult.  With a ive steam engine, some working parts cannot be shrunk as much as others. Some colours have to be modified. Yet the overall impression, whether model or prototype, has to remain the same. Only an artist can supply the mix of art and science needed to create a model which is also a working steam locomotive. Interestingly, electric locos are more amenable to being shrunken versions of the prototype – all steam parts are just dummies. Yet a certain charm can be lost.
You could run an overscale Wren on your track. You could have a resin and electric loco. Or you could have the genuine article. Wrightscale 16mm scale Wren and Tattoo
Secondly, you won’t lose money – far from it. You can pay quite a lot for a ‘me-too’ locomotive, as much as the Wrightscale you bought. The over scale Kerr Stuart Wren is advertised in the latest Sixteen Millimetre Today at £1650 or so, and these prices rise every year. Genuine Wrightscale products don’t lose value. You are in fact buying from a Studio – as recognised by Federal U.S. Law. As with any work of art, second hand prices steadily increase. You are getting a signature as well as a product. Thank you all for your confidence.
The third advantage you enjoy is very subtle. You have joined us on our journey, from the first excitement of viewing a prototype to having it run on your layout. Like us, you have experienced a piece of history. Every prototype has character and there are reasons: history, geography, economics and personalities which explain why it ended up the way it did.
So, for example, the unique Péchot wagon owes its existence, not just to the French will to win the next war in Germany, but also to the remarkable personality of Prosper Péchot.
The Kerr Stuart Tattoo 0-4-2 has its own story. It offered more power and endurance than its little sister the Wren. At the same time, the Tattoo and Wren share many family characteristics. The Wrightscale Tattoo has about 50% more running time than the Wren yet because of its 0-4-2 wheel-base, it could still be used on lightly engineered track. The prototype could tackle tight bends; the model will tackle curves down to 3’ radius. Whereas the typical Wren was used to pull skips, the Corris Railway Tattoo (no 4) was designed to assure a public service. As a contractor’s cab, it reached places that the Wren couldn’t. Customers consider all the characteristics carefully before making their choice – just as the management of the prototype railways would have done!
Is this a Works Photo or a 16mm Wrightscale Tattoo? You decide
Obviously, there is a place for freelance, semi-prototypical and museum quality models. The Garden Gauge community welcome them all.

Friday, 31 January 2020

Friends of the Baldwin Gas Mechanical



As we are on the subject of friends, we were sorry to learn of the deaths of Jim Wild and John Turner, great characters within the small world of 16mm. Derek Wiggins features a tribute to Jim in the e-magazine, Throwback Modeller (TBM) issue 13. I contributed a word or two as Jim and Colin Binnie, also sadly missed, had managed to rescue a locomotive, Hohenzollern 447, from utter obscurity. This tiny loco of German design had a conical boiler.
Do get TBM issues 13 and 14 if you can. As well as information about Jim Wild’s models, it features Colin Binnie’s unique General Arrangement of the Hz447, and the story behind this extraordinary military locomotive.
16mm scale  Baldwin Gas Mechanical, 50hp version, as used by both the French and the AEF 1916-18. Wrightscale model

The last blog explained a little of Malcolm’s fascination with another tiny giant of Military Narrow Gauge, the Baldwin Gas Mechanical locotractor. It would be good to provide a little context, by featuring two other petrol powered locomotives of the period. These were the Dick Kerr 40-45hp petrol electric tractor and the Simplex. Both were British made.
In theory, the Baldwin Gas Mechanical was developed later than both of these. 
The story of the Simplex goes right back to 1914. Although the BGM order date of 1917 is definitely after the time that the Dick Kerr was commissioned, November 1916, the story is a little more complicated. Certain aspects of the BGM date back, possibly, to the 19th century.
16mm model of the Pechot Bourdon 0-4-4-0,. The lines of the central chassis are angled in a way that is reminscent of the BGM. Model built by Henry Holdworth, photo courtesy J. Hawkesworth.
The mighty Baldwin Loco works of Philadelphia had been involved in the 14-18 War since 1915. Although the USA was not at the time a combatant, many of its businesses were arms suppliers. As the Central Powers were blockaded, most of the goods were purchased by the Allies. The French took a 19th century blueprint, the Péchot-Bourdon locomotive, to the USA. Among the first Baldwin locomotives to cross the Atlantic were these Péchot-Bourdon steam locomotives, no less than 280!
As mentioned earlier, it soon became clear that steam engines near the Front were a liability. For a start, they were far too visible to enemy artillery. Both the Germans and the Allies looked to the new Internal Combustion technology to provide smoke-free (well, relatively), spark free transport. This class of locomotive has been given various names but for convenience I’ll use the general term locotractors.
The role of the Russian Army is being reassessed; in 1916, they commissioned locotractors from Baldwin. Soon after, the French ordered 600. In my personal view, Baldwin drew both on the Péchot-Bourdon and the Russian designs for the glorious beast that is the Baldwin Gas Mechanical. The Russian locomotive is an obvious ancestor. Even an amateur can see how the coupling arrangement, large bonnet and louvred sides passed from one to the other.
Blueprint of the Pechot Bourdon chassis. It was carried by two steam bogies, each linked to the chassis by a revolutionary flexible joint and steam lines. Courtesy of the CAA, Chatellereult
It can be argued that, to reassure the French, the Baldwin works offered something that was also reminiscent of the Péchot-Bourdon. The nature of the design required a very strong chassis frame. It was supported by twin independent, sprung steam bogies. It in turn had to support the firebox and boiler arrangement while also transmitting the tractive effort of the locomotive to the train. This thinking, I feel, helped to give the Baldwin Gas Mechanical its wonderful and distinctive frames.
16mm models of a Baldwin Gas Mechanical and three forms of the Simplex. BGM by Wrightscale, Simplex models by David Smith as is the front of a Dick Kerr, just visible at left. Photo J. Hawkesworth.
Meanwhile, the British War Department were approaching the petrol locomotive from a different viewpoint. The Simplex design goes back to 1914 when the Motor Rail and Tramcar Co of Bedford offeredthe design to General Kitchener. At that time it was refused. In 1916, British High Command finally caught up with the folk on the ground and placed an order.
The main advantage of the Simplex was simplicity – the clue was in the name. The original had a channel-steel underframe and overall length was just under 9’. A 20 hp petrol engine was mounted in the middle, powering a three-speed gearbox which could run equally well in forward and reverse. Chain drives powered both axles. The driver faced sideways at the end opposite the radiator – good visibility in both directions.
The 40hp Simplex followed. The design was distinctive. The underframe was now sheet steel rather than channel, overall length was just under 12’ the driver sat in the middle rather than at one end, the ends of the frame were ballasted to improve track adhesion, the motor was more powerful and there was armour.
A 20 hp Simplex (David Smith) hauls a Pechot artillery wagon (Wrightscale) while an armoured Simplex looks on. The radiator is at one end while the driver sits sideways at the other.
This varied in degree. In the Open type, the flammable engine parts were covered with sheet metal and the driver had a canopy to keep off the worst of the weather. The Protected tractor had all this plus steel doors to the driver’s cab. The Armoured design was almost completely enclosed in sheet metal. Its beetle shape has evoked much fondness.
In number and in ‘character’, various versions of the Simplex almost rivalled the Baldwin locotractor.  A total of 590 in the four designs were supplied to the Front. It is possible that the famous confusion that hovered over the Baldwin Gas Mechanical may have been caused by the Simplex which was supplied as 20hp and 40hp. The BGM was supplied as 50 hp to the French and, slightly later, in 35 and 50hp forms to the American Expeditionary Force. A number of early histories assigned to BGMs the horse-powers 20 and 40. Could the cheeky little Simplex have caused the confusion? 
The Dick Kerr petrol-electric was another British answer to the BGM. The BGM was 23’ long, the Dick Kerr around 15’ At roughly 7 tonnes, the two designs were comparable in mass. Power was 40 hp compared to 50. Loco drivers had similar complaints about both – their agonising slowness. Both were also top heavy. Although the model does not show them, the Dick Kerr prototypes were equipped with massive re-railing bars – no doubt for good reason. The Dick Kerr had distinctive louvred side panels, just like the BGM.
16mm model of the Dick Kerr petrol tractor, built by David Smith, showing the characteristic louvred panels. Electric pick-ups can be seen on the bonnet top. someone has nicked the rerailing bar! Photo courtesy J. Hawkesworth
But the two were the products of parallel evolution. The BGM was the product of US ingenuity applied to French engineering. Only the British could have come up with the Dick Kerr. When the War Department Light Railways Programme B was put forward in the autumn of 1916, electric locomotives with overhead pickups were suggested. They would not generate steam and sparks and thus would stay out of sight of enemy artillery. The electric pick-ups proved to be an issue! Although the plan was quickly abandoned, the design specified electric pickups on locomotives. Effectively, electric power was generated from by a petrol engine; when stationary, the loco had a second use as a generator. Wherever there was aworkshop, a Dick Kerr or its sister, the Westinghouse, would be in attendance.
The specifications were put out to two companies, British Westinghouse Ltd and, slightly later, Dick Kerr Ltd. Both produced 50 pairs of locomotives. Though both designs featured detachable armour-plating, contemporary photos suggest that Dick Kerr Ltd put more thought into protecting the cab. This fact, and the delicious louvred panels have made the Dick Kerr the favourite between the two designs.
16mm Dick Kerr (David Smith) and BGM (Wrightscale). They are comparable in dimensions and power. Photo courtesy Jim Hawkesworth
There are some lovely proprietory 16mm models of both the armoured Simplex and the Dick Kerr. David Smith has done much in this field. The late Henry Holdsworth painted and weathered the models in these pohotos, to superb effect. All three of these characterful locomotives have a place on a layout, whether in war-time or post-war guise. 

Tuesday, 31 December 2019

16mm scale Baldwin Gas Mechanical



We missed a deadline and our regular advertisement didn’t appear in the latest ‘Sixteen Millimetre Today’ magazine. You will want to know what you missed. This was the 16mm model of a Baldwin Gas Mechanical locomotiv. We have taken a fascinating prototype and created a model to run on 32mm track.
16mm scale Baldwin Gas Mechanical locotractor that we meant to advertise in winter 2019. Created by Wrightscale
The originals were developed to run on the 60cm gauge railways that supplied the trenches of World War One. We have long had an interest in this vast but forgotten network – more below.
We produced these models about ten years ago, using the best suppliers we could find. Unfortunately, these companies kept closing; and as small suppliers came up for retirement, they too just closed their garage doors. It has required a lot of time and energy in finding new suppliers of the right calibre .
One of our best was Adrian Swain. We were relieved when Sarah Smith of Sarum Models was able to take over as a high quality and efficient supplier.
The steel laser-cut frames were even more of a head-ache. Our first supplier did pass us on to another company but this in turn quietly shut its doors and threw away its working tools. Well! When we did find another company, Malcolm had to redraw the frames and present them in a form that their laser computers could digest. This all had to be fitted in while we earned a living and kept up with family matters.
Here’s what we were going to say in the advertisement.
‘A batch of these interesting locomotives is going to be built or delivery early next year’ If you might like to buy one, let us know your name.’
Unfortunately, we cannot yet commit to a price because our suppliers in their turn cannot yet commit. They all quote a certain event which we keep being told will happen, but which doesn’t. This event hovers like a malign flying elephant, spreading uncertainty throughout the raft of small businesses on which we float. Thus, we will take your name without obligation, and give you an opportunity to buy once you know the price.
That is the substance of the advertisement.

THis part-assembled Wrightscale Baldwin Gas Mechanical shows the chassis frames, a standard Baldwin manufacturing feature. Photo and model MD Wright
We’d also like to share with you our delight in the model.
The prototype popped up in 1917, half-way through the Great War. In the early months, both the Allies and Central Powers realised a sad truth about the War. It was not going to be a war of movement, over quickly once one side had taken over the territory of the other. The French were not overwhelmed by the Schlieffen Plan and the Germans had a secret supply of ammonia for their ammunition. One side and then the other dug in along eastern France and the French Belgian border. Temporary trenches became permanent and the Western Front appeared.
Both sides were faced with a problem that few, at least on the Allied side, had anticipated – how to feed, water and quarter millions of soldiers and their artillery. The French, thanks to almost heroic efforts by an officer in their Artillery, Prosper Péchot, had a 19th century railway system which could be adapted. The Germans, always on the alert for good ideas, copied this promising system in the 1890s.
Colonel Péchot in 1907. Photograph courtesy of Raymond PECHOT
This wonder-working system depended on 60cm (roughly 2’)  gauge prefabricated track which could be quickly laid, or relaid wherever supply trains were required. Thanks to clever design using sound engineering principles, these miniature railways could support heavy trains, pulled by powerful locomotives. The horses, mules and humans who would otherwise have had to transport millions, yes millions, of tonnes of supplies in thoroughly inhumane conditions were spared. War Horse could eat his oats in (relatively) safe conditions.
The system was rapidly adapted. Temporary track gave way to proper permanent way. Importantly, a substitute was found for steam locomotives. By day, these sent up a plume of smoke, by night, a shower of sparks, an absolute gift for opposition artillery. By 1917, a number of designs of internal combustion engines had reached the tracks. Among the range of models put forward were rail-mounted cars. Outstanding among the Allied designs were the Baldwin locotractors. On the German side, Benzolloks (running on petrol) and Dieselloks appeared
For a number of reasons, the Baldwin Gas Mechanical locotractor built by the Baldwin Works of Philadelphia has inspired the greatest affection.
On account of the numbers built, it was sighted everywhere. When the USA entered the War in 1917, their AEF ordered 109 BGMs and 61 of the 35 hp version. Nineteen (or so) never crossed the Atlantic. An even larger number were made for the French – between 535 and 600, depending on the authority. If you want to know more about the numbering, Rich Dunn gives a good account in his ‘Narrow Gauge to No Man’s Land’ pp 98 to 109. Another excellent account is given in Dr Christian Cénac’s ‘Soixante centimetres pour ravitailler les fronts de la guerre de 14-18’
Partly built Wrightscale 16mm scale Baldwin Gas Mechanical
The BGM was seen in a number of settings – training camps, forestry railways, maintenance, shunting and, most importantly of all, taking supplies forward to the Front. The locotractors had the priceless advantage of being less visible than steam engines. They could run all day and night, as long as they were regularly refuelled. They were much easier to stop and start than a steam engine. As the driver sat side-on, reverse was no more difficult than going forward.  Imagine how this must have improved the lot of a squaddy under fire!
The BGM was truly international. We believe that the French/AEF design originated with an earlier locotractor made for the Russian Government. This was in 76cm (roughly 2’6”) gauge – the eastern front also had light railways though never to the extent of the west.
The BGM had character – so much locomotive perched on so small a wheelbase – the vast yet reassuring ‘face’ - the fascinating louvred sides and the frames, the frames, the frames. It was not so much a chunk of metal, but an embodiment of the spirit of US manufacture. The Baldwin Works combined the rugged individualism with the new techniques of the assembly line.
A Baldwin Works Assembly hall pictured in 1915 showing how rugged individualism could be happily combined with the techniques of the assembly line. Photo courtesy Raymond PECHOT
On the one hand, Baldwin could not have achieved its vast productivity without a system. Each product was built in a huge hangar where a team could perform an operation then move on to perform the same on the next. Yet at the same time, these teams could improvise where needed. If the factory drawing didn’t quite work, the foreman could devise a work-round and trust the team to deliver. The BGM design shows the best of US flair of the period.
An enticing air of mystery still hangs about the BGM. Historians continue to argue about the numbering and hoiw to track down missing examples.  When the US government placed the order with the Baldwin Locomotive Company, they may well have stipulated 20 and 40 horsepower. What they got were 35 and 50. This may have been because the more powerful gasoline engines were more readily available. Certainly, the greater power was more useful under battlefield conditions – more likely to achieve the theoretical speeds of 6.4 kph (4 mph) and 12.8 kph (8 mph) in top gear.
They had disadvantages, the main one being that their power output could be less than a third of a steam loco. It didn’t always achieve the quoted top speed. Soon the people in the field did what they always do - demand more power.
Though track adhesion was quite good – four driving wheels took 100% of the loco’s weight – the corollary of the neat wheelbase was a large overhang front and rear.  It tended to jump off the track. Furthermore, as the design was pushing the envelope of contemporary design, the gearbox and clutch were unreliable. There was another, disadvantage, plain as the nose on its face. The gas/petrol/essence was carried in a tank on top of the bonnet. When it had just been refuelled, this raised the centre of gravity. When it was nearly empty of liquid, the cylinder remained full of hydro-carbon gas, highly vulnerable to stray ordinance.
Some unpatriotic servicemen were photographed driving the British Simplex and the French Schneider 0-6-0 petrol loco.
A lovely example of the 50hp BGM is preserved at Froissy, Somme
The Baldwin locotractor has had a long afterlife, partly because it was, in its own terms, an excellent loco and partly because prototypes were plentiful. Long after the First World War, they were used in military camps in the USA – Camp Humphreys East Virginia, the Proving Grounds at Aberdeen Maryland, Fort Benning etc. Many were sold as War surplus.  Moelwyn on the Festiniog Railway is a heavily disguised Baldwin locotractor. Lovely examples are also preserved in France.
These prototypes keep interest alive; we have had encouraging interest in the model
The Wrightscale model for comparison

Saturday, 23 November 2019

Wrightscale and military railways



The Péchot Story and Epinal
We are delighted to see that Epinal has rediscovered its military heritage! One site, the Fortiff'Séré - Le site web & l'association Séré de Rivières run by Cédric and Julie Vaubourg has ample photographs showing how the system is being restored.
A Séré de Rivières fort, lovingly restored. A 60cm railway runs over the defensive ditch in through the gate. THis is Uxegney near Toul which was quicker to preserve its heritage. Photo Malcolm Wright
As enthusiasts of the heritage of Péchot military railways, we visited Epinal in the early Oughties. In those days, it seemed unaware of its interesting heritage. So here is some background.
Epinal is the county town (chef lieu de département) of Vosges in eastern France. As such, for many years it was considered vulnerable to invaders from across the nearby Rhine.It was therefore a centre for fortifications, gradually increasing in complexity. A castle dominates the centre of town.
After the Franco-Prussian War 1870-1 and the loss of the department of Haut Rhin to the east, Epinal became a frontier town. In 1874, smarting from their defeat, the French government authorised General Séré de Rivières to plan a line of defences. These stretched from the Channel to the Mediterranean; there were also naval forts defending the Atlantic approaches.
Epinal found itself a centre for these new fortifications, planned, built and commissioned between 1874 and 1882.
These new forts, several per city, were huge (a typical outer face was 100 metres long) and earth-sheltered. Each was surrounded by a ditch; the spoil from the ditch was used to construct a glacis (vast sloping outer wall) as further protection. Although many forts were rectangular, where conditions dictated, they could be other four-sided or five sided shapes, thus the name polygone.   At the height of building the project absorbed up to one-tenth of the entire national budget.
What high explosive could do to a fort, in this case Maubeuge. Photo from Illustration magazine courtesy MD Wright
It was a huge undertaking but almost as soon as the forts were built, they were out of date. Melinite, a precursor of TNT, was introduced. In 1886, the government experimentally bombarded the fort of Malmaison with the new high explosive shells. The Press got wind of the experiment and turned out to watch.
The beautiful, if slightly old-fashioned, fort was reduced to rubble in an afternoon. If the fort had been defended all the occupants would have died, if not from a direct hit, from building collapse. The Press weren’t going to keep quiet about this threat to Our Boys. Séré de Rivières and the Committee for Fortifications were ordered to sort out the problem. Urgently.
They came up with a plan. The forts would be safe as long as the opposition couldn’t get within range. This meant that each fort had to be surrounded with mini-forts. As guns became more sophisticated, the mini-forts had to be surrounded with micro-forts and these in turn with buried guns batteries. The central fort was buried, with  a retractable gun turret and the ammunition was stored deep underground. The principle was sound. During the First World War, it took the Germans nearly a fortnight to subdue a Belgian fort which had no ring of defence. The Verdun system, which was well-defended, held out during the long and savage Battle of Verdun.
But … There were a few ‘buts.’  The first problem was cost. The Treasury could not pay to build a defensive screen all the way down France. They decided to concentrate on the border with Germany – Belgium, Britain and Italy seemed less of a threat. This was to prove a mistake. Frontier defences would be concentrated on four centres – Verdun, Epinal, Toul-Nancy and Belfort near the Swiss border. Thus Epinal which had a ring of sixteen forts had these protected by thirty for redoutes and these in turn by sixty four gun batteries.
Prosper Péchot photographed in 1907, courtesy Raymond PECHOT
Solving this problem generated a new one. To ensure that all these defences had the latest in guns and ammunition, they needed more than footpaths and a few mules. Fortunately, a solution was at hand - developed for the French Army by one of their own.
Prosper Péchot, an officer in the Artillery, had developed an ingenious portable railway in 60cm gauge. In ‘Colonel Péchot: Tracks to the trenches,’ Sarah Wright has described how he took ideas from the Decauville Company, the slate quarries of Wales, the Darjeeling Himalaya Railway and developments in North America to create a system of portable railways. Small locomotives could run on light track without disturbing the substrate – well, not very much. Enormous loads could be carried on rolling stock as long as such loads were carried on enough axles. Best of all, the trains could cope with track laid on hilly ground.
He, unfortunately, had rivals. The French Génie (Sappers) preferred metre gauge as this was proven technology. The ground around all these forts was hilly. Verdun had the Woevre, Toul the Argonne (politely known as the Parc National de Lorraine), Belfort the Alps and Epinal the Vosges. The French Army decided to spend a year testing both.
Bois l'Abbe was a minor fort in the system protecting Toul. Enthusiasts have recently relaid the 60cm railway which used to connect it to other forts. Photo MD Wright.
 60 cm was tested  between Toul and Fort Lucey, perched on a hill.  Metre gauge was to be tested above Epinal. It was planned to create a system between the forts of Girancourt and Thiéha. By spring 1888, Toul and Lucey were linked. They were nowhere near building a metre gauge line. The Génie hoped they could cover up the problem; when the tour of inspection arrived, they were treated to a slap-up dinner in town. When the inspectors arrived at Toul, they were given a picnic on the glacis at Lucey, having travelled up on a functioning 60cm railway.
The workhorse of the 60cm system was this sturdy, well-sprung wagon capable of taking ten tonnes of supplies along light track. 16mm Wrightscale model
Justice was served. 60cm was proclaimed victor.
This ingenious 60cm gauge rail-mounted crane could handle heavy ammunition safely . 16mm Wrightscale model
Other problems were not immediately solved. Hygiene was one. Human beings produce wet and dry manure. If the castle is a lofty construction, high above the heads of attackers, such products are welcome additional ammunition. Visitors to a typical medieval castle can admire the garderobes, handily placed over of the opposition! When the fortification is underground, waste not so welcome. It would trickle into the living-quarters, ammunition and water supplies. Nineteenth century France found n adequate solution.
Revolving gun turret, cosily earth-sheltered. Unfortunately, it was not well ventilated. Photographed at Villey-le-sec (near Toul) by MD Wright
Another question was ventilation, a perennial problem for underground work-places. An elaborate system of passive-stack ventilation ensured a brisk enough air turnaround for normal life. When we visited an underground dormitory, the air smelled fresh. Unfortunately, this was not adequate for heavy work underground with all the nitrogen compounds produced by high explosives. A few minutes in these conditions produced nausea and headaches. Prolonged exposure was dangerous to health.
For these reasons, forts rapidly became intolerable under siege conditions. Epinal was never truly tested. During World War One, Verdun suffered a ferocious attack; even when it was clear that the Germans were preparing their assault in March 1916, Forts Vaux and Douaumont were not properly defended. Only when Pétain introduced troop rotation was it possible to maintain a garrison in the remaining system.
Gate to fort Girancourt, near Epinal. Until recently, this was being allowed to return to Nature. Photo by MD Wright
After 1918, the frontier was pushed eastwards and the Séré de Rivières defences were made redundant. The system in the Toul-Nancy area was used until 1940 for training. When the Second World War was imminent, other forts were given some attention. The classic ‘umbrellas’ – a post supporting strands of barbed wire - as used around the Maginot line - were installed around many old Séré forts. They were still in evidence around Girancourt in 2004, concealed in vegetation.
Until the late 20th century, many fort were still used by the Army. These were then released into the care of enthusiasts, and a number of forts were rescued. Typical would be the ‘La Citadelle’ Association of Villey-le-Sec near Toul which had a 60cm working tourist railway by 2007.  Uxegney, Lucey (both Toul), Batterie de l’Eperon (above Nancy) also had enthusiasts’ groups.
Around Epinal, forts such as Girancourt and Thiéha submerged into the forest. In the years after the War, they had been returned to the local commune who saw in the concealed ditches, barbed wire etc nothing but hazards so they were fenced off and the public kept out. Fortunately they are now, as of 2019, being rescued. The Fortiff’Séré website/facebook gives details; we were particularly gratified to see Girancourt and Thiéha emerging from the trees and brambles. 
Gate to fort Thiéha near Epinal, also being retirned to Nature. Photo MD Wright
As well as 'Colonel Péchot: Tracks To The Trenches', see if you can find a copy of 'Chemins de fer militaries a voie de 60' by Wahl and Metz.